News

Trailfinders questions if PCR tests ‘contrived to discourage travel’

Trailfinders has launched an attack on the purpose of the government’s PCR testing regime, claiming that only a small number are used for genomic sequencing to detect Covid ‘variants of concern’.

In a blog post, the firm questioned whether tests on return were “contrived to discourage travel, rather than aid health control?”.

The blog said: “The identification of new variants we are told, is why travellers have to undertake a PCR test on return.

“However, in the three-week period from July 1, only 354 of these tests were genomic sequenced to identify new variants of concern out of 500,000 tests it is reported. Of the 1.4% who tested positive (6,977) out of the half million tests, this means just 5% of those were sequenced. This even includes those coming from red list countries.

“On this basis government are either not terribly concerned about new variants, or believe only a very small number of tests are needed to establish them.”

It continued: “To give context to the 6,977 positive tests from those returning from abroad: Over the period of this data 1-21 July, there were 761,115 positive tests for Covid in the UK, making the returning travellers less than 1% of the total. Perhaps the 36,243 positive tests a day on average in the UK over this period were sufficient to pick up new strains?

“With only 1 in 1,412 tests of returning travellers sequenced, are day 2 and day 8 PCR tests contrived to discourage travel, rather than aid health control?”

The post concluded: “If the government are content to sequence a tiny sample (118 per week based on these numbers), then there are better ways: saving the cost and hassle for travellers.

“To fly back into the UK we are obliged to fill in a ‘passenger locator form’. Every 1,412th person submitting a form could be instructed to get a Day 2 test at an NHS testing centre. The equivalent of a random bag check at customs when you go through the green channel. QED

“Even the fully vaccinated returning from green list countries, with very few cases, are required to undergo a day 2 test. Is the reason for these tests to deter travel rather than to uncover new variants? The data suggests this may well be the case.”

Share article

View Comments

Jacobs Media Group is honoured to be the recipient of the 2020 Queen's Award for Enterprise.

The highest official awards for UK businesses since being established by royal warrant in 1965. Read more.